Banana Bay Resort & Marina - Marathon - Reviews

Banana Bay is a good value... – Posted 4 Dec 2010

Good

Banana Bay is a good value for what you get, as long as you're not expecting a prefabricated resort. Part of the charm of the keys is that they're a... more on MYTravelGuide

Not as pictured... – Posted 3 Oct 2010

Okay

The hotel was not as pictured on Travel Website.The facility is not in good shape.Needs to be fixed up.... more on Travelocity

Nice, quiet, clean... – Posted 24 Apr 2010

Good

A very average keys hotel, nice enough, beautiful location. Could use some updating, but for the price,it was a good value. Clean, quiet rooms. Our... more on Travelocity

Pleasant, but a few... – Posted 7 Apr 2010

Okay

. . . beware of an idealized website and listing. Many items offered are not available -- no morning paper, for instance. Also, while rooms and bath... more on Travelocity

Nice experience... – Posted 12 Nov 2009

Good

Nice hotel, large heated poo, clean room, nice marina (if you have a boat with you). I would stay again. Only thing is, travel website says they have ... more on Travelocity

Would recommend this hotel!... – Posted 25 Jun 2009

Good

Would recommend this hotel!... more on Zoover

Not as advertised... – Posted 1 May 2009

Okay

The photo on the website is not a photo of this location as we discovered. There was an extra cost for a garden/pool view room which I paid for. When ... more on Travelocity

Nice place... – Posted 6 Apr 2009

Good

Stayed there for couple days, despite unfavorable comments on this site, and did not regret.Very good value for money we paid (we received a good... more on Travelocity

would not recommend... – Posted 6 Feb 2009

Mediocre

Room was not as described, garden view was a few bushes and unkept trees between our room and the highway, no porch or veranda. Could use a lot of... more on Travelocity

Dirty and Old... – Posted 11 Jan 2009

Okay

We arrived on Jan. 1, 2009 which is a very busy time for the Keys.This resort is very quiet and small.The room was not very clean at all and very... more on Travelocity

DO NOT STAY HERE!... – Posted 20 Nov 2008

Horrible

We booked a room from November 16 to November 19.The hallway in the motel smelled like mildew.The room had red ants that bit.We went to the pool and... more on Travelocity

Large pool and large rooms,... – Posted 7 Jul 2008

Good

Large pool and large rooms, and tropical foliage.Rooms in a different building than office. Rooms not clean.“The hotel personnel were very friendly.... more on MYTravelGuide