Hilton Garden Inn New York/West 35th Street - Reviews

Christmas Downer... – Posted 28 Dec 2011

Horrible

Surprised to read such good reviews of this hotel. As a longtime Hilton HHonors member, found this property to be the worst experience ever. Elevators are more like cattle cars, the baggage check was

It was perfect for a little... – Posted 1 Dec 2011

Excellent

It was perfect for a little two day getaway fun weekend! Location was perfect! Hotel is clean, bed was comfortable, view was beautiful (corner room... more on MYTravelGuide

Great location, the room was... – Posted 28 Oct 2011

Excellent

Great location, the room was very clean and in great shape with very comfortable bed and nice bathroom.... more on MYTravelGuide

Excellent location with nice, ... – Posted 9 Sep 2011

Excellent

Excellent location with nice, clean, and comfortable rooms. Friendly staff.... more on MYTravelGuide

Very friendly staff. No staff ... – Posted 1 Aug 2011

Good

Very friendly staff. No staff to assist with baggage, made parking and getting to room and leaving room on day of check-out very difficult. Was not... more on MYTravelGuide

The staff always greeted us... – Posted 19 Jul 2011

Excellent

The staff always greeted us when we walked through the lobby, and they offered us bottled water.... more on MYTravelGuide

Great hotel!!... – Posted 10 Jul 2011

Good

I booked a room the eve of the Xmas blizzard'10 and we were stuck in NYCfor an extra day as the trains to CT. were not running.I called down to the... more on Travelocity

very clean and well... – Posted 3 Jun 2011

Excellent

very clean and well maintained.... more on MYTravelGuide

Location, Great Service and... – Posted 6 May 2011

Excellent

It takes me a lot to stay at the same hotel more than once, since I love the adventure of staying in different hotels in New York City. The Hilton... more on IgoUgo

Great Experience.... – Posted 27 Mar 2011

Good

Stayed 1 night at this hotel. Very close to MSG and main transit areas. Staff was very nice and helpful. Room was great. Big for NY hotels and... more on Travelocity

Excellent... – Posted 5 Mar 2011

Excellent

This was a wonderful hotel experience.The room was large, new, clean and quiet.Free internet, free cookies, very nice staff (ask for XYZ).I have... more on Travelocity

nice find!... – Posted 26 Feb 2011

Excellent

room was comfy and surprisingly quiet!window can be opened for some fresh air which is unusual!love having a REAL coffeemaker in the room rather than ... more on Travelocity

Great location, staff, and... – Posted 22 Dec 2010

Excellent

Great location, staff, and great room with a view. Beds were very comfortable. Price was good for the quality of the hotel. It was quiet.... more on MYTravelGuide

Hilton Experience... – Posted 24 Nov 2010

Good

It's what you expect from the Hilton brand. More about the Hilton than it is about New York as once you are checked in, you could be anywhere usa. Super clean, super neat, super comfortable. Great loc

Great hotel!... – Posted 26 Oct 2010

Excellent

Stayed here for 1-night and I must say it was definitely worth the price.The room is small but the space was utilized well and everything was very... more on Travelocity

Great Place To Stay... – Posted 10 Sep 2010

Excellent

Were in New York for the U s Open TennisTournament in August, 2010.The hotel was outstanding.The room looked out onto Macys and the Empire State Bldg ... more on Travelocity

Great Place to Stay in... – Posted 15 Jul 2010

Excellent

This was my second time to stay at the Hilton Garden Inn, I was very pleased on both occasions. The rooms are clean, well appointed, and comfortable. ... more on Travelocity

Would Stay Again... – Posted 11 Jul 2010

Excellent

It was a quick painless check-in. The room was already ready for us when we arrived, as requested (we requested a quiet room).The small work out room ... more on Travelocity

Great hotel... – Posted 6 Feb 2010

Excellent

I was pleasantly surprised with this hotel.It was so close to Macy's, the subway, shopping on 34th and 5th.The room was very comfortable and the... more on Travelocity

Nothing special... – Posted 23 Jan 2010

Okay

I stayed here for 2 nights.The BED is VERY FIRM!!The mattress has a knob to adjust the firmness but I didn't notice any difference.The room was clean ... more on Travelocity

Great little hotel in Midtown... – Posted 26 Sep 2009

Excellent

between 5th & 6th Avenues...clean, comtemporary furnishings, friendly/helpful staff...would definitely stay here again.Avoid the Gray Line tour the... more on Travelocity

I Want to Be a Part of It!... – Posted 1 Aug 2009

Good

On my recent trip to the USA I left Mr Tart to book the hotel for New York. Normally I wouldn’t leave it to him as I’d end up in the cheapest hostel... more on IgoUgo