Hotel Carter - Reviews

I would stay again... – Posted 14 May 2012

Good

stayed in April 2012. The room was clean and the bathroom was also clean. The front desk staff were very pleasant and helpful. There are no frills but the location makes up for all that.

HOTEL CARTER SUCKSS!!... – Posted 7 Sep 2011

Horrible

dont bother, went there, stayed 2 different times, two different floors,, same thing mold, everything broken, walls falling apart, rooms smelling like roach and rat poo. Sick, dont bother, you can fi

shit hole... – Posted 19 Aug 2011

Horrible

stay away from this godforgotten place!!!

Reasonable ... – Posted 24 Mar 2011

Good

The room wasn't scrubbed from top to bottom like more expensive hotels. You got what you paid for. The hot water has a "trick" to it and it takes 10 minutes to get it warm enough to get in. No hangers

NY Regulars... – Posted 30 Dec 2010

Horrible

This was the WORST hotel ever!!!!!!!! Dirty, grafitti in the rooms, very unsafe!!! Have been going to NYC for 40+ yrs, and this was the worst ever!

DIRTY, DANGEROUS, CHEATS,... – Posted 24 Nov 2010

Horrible

Dirty rooms, no cable, hostile staff, girl was murdered in here ca. 2008 and the staff didn't even get it; they will happily rip you off and then tell you to go do yourself if you complain. Stay Away

SDNYC... – Posted 18 Oct 2010

Good

For the price and location you can't miss. Sure this isn't your average hotel, but if all you need it for it to sleep and bath it's perfect. Especially for budget minded people staying here will make

The price and location can't... – Posted 28 Sep 2010

Good

Sure, it needs to be vacuumed and the shower needs to be scrubbed, but the sheets were clean, we had a handful of good tv channels, and slept well. I didn't find it too noisy at all. The AC and mach

Good substitute of hostel... – Posted 7 Sep 2010

Mediocre

Actually if you are 2 people of more this hotel is a good substitute of hostel. Ideal location just half-block from Times Square and 42th street transit center, in-room bathroom, comfortable beds, low

nightmare!... – Posted 13 Aug 2010

Horrible

Horrible hotel!! stay away!!! dirty, all furniture were broken!! my worst experience ever!

worst hotel... – Posted 9 Aug 2010

Horrible

stayed for 2 nights with my family. Had to move first thing because there was no cable service. The room was dirty, no room service. The first night minimal sleep because of construction. Only good th

dottie and jewel enjoy this... – Posted 4 May 2010

Good

I cant believe all the negative posts about this hotel, I stay here with my little girl who works in the city every week,the people who are working here are great, very friendly and helpful, the rooms

Conde Naste voted worst hotel ... – Posted 12 Apr 2010

Horrible

I think they have had this title for many years. The sheets are not changed, windows don't close, faucets fall off in hands, water temp not regulated, cochroaches are not even afraid of humans.

Overpriced motel.... – Posted 6 Apr 2010

Horrible

No lightbulb in our room; we reported it upon arrival, and they never fixed it. The words "DIRTY SLUT" were written on the picture frame above the bed. Pillowcases read: "I'm yours". We found an item

Worst hotel ever... – Posted 25 Mar 2010

Horrible

Disgusting. Cleaning and bed/bathroom clothes changed every other day (they say). Nothing works (lamps, heating, bathtub, TV, etc.). Full of garbage, with cockroaches and rats. It was a night of terro

the worst stay EVER... – Posted 22 Mar 2010

Horrible

the most disgusting place to stay! Dirty, with rats jjjjjj HORRIBLE!!!!!!!