Hotels
Flights
Cars
Holidays
Trips
Home
»
United States
»
New York
»
Shelter Island
»
Hotels
Shelter Island Guide
Shelter Island Hotels
Flights to Shelter Island
Shelter Island Trends
Select to narrow hotel list
Stars
Any
3-star hotels in Shelter Island
Property type
Any
Hotels in Shelter Island
Nearby Cities
(2 mi)
Shelter Island Heights Hotels
(4 mi)
Greenport Hotels
(5 mi)
East Marion Hotels
(6 mi)
Southold Hotels
(6 mi)
Sag Harbor Hotels
(6 mi)
Orient Hotels
(7 mi)
Bridgehampton Hotels
(8 mi)
Peconic Hotels
Shelter Island Hotels
« Prev
—
Next »
2 Shelter Island Hotels
Sort:
Popularity
Price
Name
Stars
Distance
£158-£336
Get Rates
see photos
Sunset Beach
map
details
Moderate
Popularity ranking
#1
of 2
35 Shore Road Shelter Island, NY
see website
see rates
+1 631 749 2001
Recent reviews
1.5
/ 5 average rating
reviews
Jul 14 2007
"hated 1. the big long black "
Get Rates
see photos
Azalea House
map
details
Moderate
Popularity ranking
#2
of 2
1 Thomas Avenue Shelter Island, NY
see website
see rates
6317494252
Recent reviews
3.0
/ 5 average rating
reviews
Aug 21 2008
"pros: Inexpensive, fabulous"
« Prev
1
Next »
close
Get hotel rates
Where
Check-in
Check-out
Guests
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Rooms
1
2
Shelter Island Hotel Search
Where
Check-in
MM/DD/YYYY
Check-out
MM/DD/YYYY
Rooms
1
2
Guests
1
2
3
4
Get Rates
Get Rates
Shelter Island Hotels
Cheap flights to Shelter Island
$221
Fort Lauderdale (FLL)
$211
West Palm Beach (PBI)
$237
Orlando (MCO)
$215
Charlotte (CLT)
$321
Los Angeles (LAX)
$321
Tampa (TPA)
$371
Phoenix (PHX)
$309
Atlanta (ATL)
$409
San Diego (SAN)
$314
Louisville (SDF)
$213
Pittsburgh (PIT)
$409
Philadelphia (PHL)
$309
Columbus (CMH)
$295
Indianapolis (IND)
$377
South Bend (SBN)
$361
Gainesville (GNV)
$253
Rochester (ROC)
$397
Huntsville (HSV)
$575
Ontario (ONT)
$512
Jackson (JAN)
| 
Moderate 
