The Yorktowne Hotel - Reviews

Loved it and would return if... – Posted 31 Dec 2011

Excellent

Loved it and would return if we are in the area again. The staff were so friendly, the room wonderful, and the lobby beautiful!... more on MYTravelGuide

Very comfortable hotel, at... – Posted 9 Dec 2011

Excellent

Very comfortable hotel, at the heart of York business center. Access to the Inter State.... more on MYTravelGuide

Would not consider this a 3.5 ... – Posted 5 Dec 2011

Mediocre

Would not consider this a 3.5 star at all. Primarily due to the cleanliness and overall feel of this hotel--dim & dated. The dated feel does not come ... more on MYTravelGuide

Would stay again.... – Posted 24 Nov 2011

Good

Would stay again.... more on MYTravelGuide

This hotel is listed as... – Posted 13 Nov 2011

Horrible

This hotel is listed as historic. Upon entry it gives a good impression, but the luxuriously appointed rooms were a definite disappointment. Modern... more on MYTravelGuide

Nobody should keep a hotel... – Posted 12 Nov 2011

Horrible

Nobody should keep a hotel like this open.... more on MYTravelGuide

Classy historic hotel. Valet... – Posted 25 Oct 2011

Excellent

Classy historic hotel. Valet parking is good for the downtown area, but it costs $8 per night + tip. Restaurant had a good looking menu, but we did... more on MYTravelGuide

Not only dated, but worn out. ... – Posted 20 Oct 2011

Mediocre

Not only dated, but worn out. I would not stay there with my partner again for free. A clean motel 6 would be better. Restaurant staff was poorly... more on MYTravelGuide

It's historical which is a... – Posted 14 Oct 2011

Okay

It's historical which is a nice feeling but really needs work!!... more on MYTravelGuide

Well past its prime, in need... – Posted 9 Oct 2011

Horrible

Well past its prime, in need of total refurbishment.... more on MYTravelGuide

Not a chain hotel that has... – Posted 2 Oct 2011

Good

Not a chain hotel that has charm and character. The hotel is old but as to the unique look and feel. Very friendly staff with good restaurant and bar.... more on MYTravelGuide

Very old, but nice and clean. ... – Posted 1 Oct 2011

Good

Very old, but nice and clean. I don't like other people driving my car and the valet parking was required if you parked at the hotel.... more on MYTravelGuide

The Yorktown hotel looks... – Posted 21 Sep 2011

Okay

The Yorktown hotel looks great form the outside and in the lobby. We felt like we were in a very high priced hotel, then we got to our room. The room ... more on MYTravelGuide

It was a horrible place I... – Posted 15 Sep 2011

Horrible

It was a horrible place I didn't even stay the night our bedroom looks cleaner and more pleasing to the human eye than this room.... more on MYTravelGuide

We enjoyed our short stay at... – Posted 13 Sep 2011

Good

We enjoyed our short stay at the Yorktown Hotel. The staff was very helpful locating a room that would meet our needs. The room was clean, quiet,... more on MYTravelGuide

Excellent hotel & staff.... – Posted 9 Sep 2011

Excellent

Excellent hotel & staff. Rooms are elegant and definitely takes you back in time with the 1920s feel. I will definitely try staying there again in... more on MYTravelGuide

Excellent hotel, valet... – Posted 29 Jul 2011

Good

Excellent hotel, valet parking only, andthe staff was very accommodating! Rooms were very nice andclean.... more on MYTravelGuide

We enjoyed the historical... – Posted 15 Jul 2011

Good

We enjoyed the historical building and location of the hotel. The rooms were large but needed updating. Beds were comfortable but too small for two... more on MYTravelGuide

The hotel is historic, but... – Posted 20 Jun 2011

Good

The hotel is historic, but the room could definitely use some updates.... more on MYTravelGuide

Very noisy from neighbor... – Posted 24 May 2011

Horrible

Very noisy from neighbor rooms. Further we had to pay for parking, no free breakfast. I regret I booked this hotel. I would have been much happier... more on MYTravelGuide

The hotel is on the Historic... – Posted 14 Apr 2011

Excellent

The hotel is on the Historic Registry. It may be old but the room we stayed in was nice. The view from the 8th floor was spectacular. The room was... more on MYTravelGuide

The Yorktowne is an old hotel ... – Posted 6 Dec 2010

Excellent

The Yorktowne is an old hotel and still retains a lot of the original features. Items like the lobby furniture and the dressers in the rooms are very ... more on MYTravelGuide

This hotel would appeal for... – Posted 12 Oct 2010

Good

This hotel would appeal for those with an appreciation for historical sites, but if looking for practicality (e.g. free breakfast, free parking),... more on MYTravelGuide

I had traveled almost 5 hours ... – Posted 18 Sep 2010

Horrible

I had traveled almost 5 hours to this hotel for fair week. My tickets for an expensive concert were in the glove box (we had just placed them in... more on MYTravelGuide

Beautiful lobby.Rooms were... – Posted 12 Apr 2010

Okay

Beautiful lobby.Rooms were terrible, Caulk peeling up, old carpet, old and poor fixtures“It may be a historic hotel, but unless they come up with 20... more on MYTravelGuide

The service was great and so... – Posted 9 Apr 2010

Excellent

The service was great and so was the location.Paying for parking everyday was a bit much.“Love the hotel and the people that were there to serve us... more on MYTravelGuide

The grill was OK and Menina... – Posted 14 Oct 2009

Horrible

The grill was OK and Menina at the front desk was the only positive point.Old, out of date, no amenities, poor maid service, uncomfortable... more on MYTravelGuide

Exactly as expected.... – Posted 30 Sep 2009

Good

The Yorktowne is an old-styled grand hotel and the experience there exactly fits the stereotype of that sort of property.The main room is Victorian... more on Travelocity

Great decor and ambiance... – Posted 28 Sep 2009

Excellent

Great decor and ambiance.Nothing.“Great friendly staff.”... more on MYTravelGuide

The staff was very helpful... – Posted 1 Sep 2009

Excellent

The staff was very helpful and very nice.No pool. very unhappy that such a high quality hotel had no pool!“The hotel staff was very nice. The hotel... more on MYTravelGuide

Wonderful older hotel... – Posted 31 Aug 2009

Horrible

Wonderful older hotel retrofitted and refurbished.Parking was terrible, charged extra for my child too!“A nice hotel, in what appears to be the heart ... more on MYTravelGuide

Friendly staff and historic... – Posted 11 Aug 2009

Excellent

Friendly staff and historic beauty of the facility.“Beautiful historic building. Close enough to Hershey or Harrisburg to make the stay worth it. If... more on MYTravelGuide

The bed was okNo Pool and/or ... – Posted 19 Jul 2009

Horrible

The bed was okNo Pool and/or spa very small rooms and very old and worn out rooms.“The room is very small and very worn out. They need to upgrade... more on MYTravelGuide

The staff couldn't be... – Posted 11 Jul 2009

Excellent

The staff couldn't be friendlier or more professional, they were FANTASTIC.The shower almost burned me and froze my daughter. Water pressure problems.... more on MYTravelGuide

The room was huge and... – Posted 1 Jul 2009

Excellent

The room was huge and well-kept, the front desk and housekeeping staff were friendly and helpful, and the business center and workout room were... more on MYTravelGuide

Downtown location, walk to... – Posted 1 Jun 2009

Excellent

Downtown location, walk to restaurantsBeds WAY TOO HARD“This is a beautiful, historic hotel in the heart of York. Warm, welcoming staff and... more on MYTravelGuide

Large room, a good window... – Posted 30 May 2009

Okay

Large room, a good window view and quiet.Room was worn and shabby.“Newly tiled bathroom with a new shower head. Also had a new flat screen TV but the ... more on MYTravelGuide

The hotel had beautiful... – Posted 22 Apr 2009

Excellent

The hotel had beautiful architectural detail.The bathroom was clean but not remodeled yet.“I would go back to this hotel in a heartbeat. The... more on MYTravelGuide

Good location.Sheets and... – Posted 22 Apr 2009

Mediocre

Good location.Sheets and pillows smelled.“I am from York and the Yorktowne Hotel always had a good reputation. We waited for our room at check-in and ... more on MYTravelGuide

Great bar/restaurant andnice... – Posted 1 Apr 2009

Okay

Great bar/restaurant andnice location.Outdated, tiny bathroom. Furniture needs updating.“Overall, I was pleased with my stay. The furnishings were a... more on MYTravelGuide

Very old rooms,very loud area ... – Posted 13 Mar 2009

Horrible

Very old rooms,very loud area at night nothing updated just plain old.“Would not recommend, bad area of town, very loud at night, rooms are so old... more on MYTravelGuide

Is a gem. The cleaning staff... – Posted 31 Jan 2009

Excellent

Is a gem. The cleaning staff is so helpful.“We always feel safe and comfortable at the Yorktown hotel. Our car is probably safer here than anywhere... more on MYTravelGuide

Clean rooms andnice staff... – Posted 27 Nov 2008

Good

Clean rooms andnice staff.Location andvalet parking. Hotel in located in the historical district of York PA. Hotel owned valet parking cost me $7.00... more on MYTravelGuide

Excellent staff and very... – Posted 20 Oct 2008

Excellent

Excellent staff and very accommodating.Needs to be remodeled which they're in the process of doing. The hotel staff was great and very helpful. Would ... more on MYTravelGuide

The downstairs area was very... – Posted 5 Sep 2008

Horrible

The downstairs area was very pretty.In the bad part of the city. This hotel was in a very bad part of York PA. The rooms need an update, and maids to ... more on MYTravelGuide

The staff was really... – Posted 5 Sep 2008

Mediocre

The staff was really friendly, no problem to change rooms or to check out late. The rooms were huge.It's right downtown in a bad neighborhood. There... more on MYTravelGuide

Beautiful upstairs corner... – Posted 5 Sep 2008

Excellent

Beautiful upstairs corner room, bright and cheery.Parking is sometimes difficult. Have stayed here before and it's always consistent, charming and I... more on MYTravelGuide