Humphreys Half Moon Inn

Excellent Location, Horrible Beds, Reprehensive Ma

Pros: Shelter Island is beautiful, the concert area in very nice, and the live music was pleasant. The room itself had a nice, large TV and new amenities. The shower had good pressure and the restroom was clean and large.

Cons: The bed was HORRIBLE. It was extremely loud and springy, and uncomfortable. There is a ridiculous $10 "resort fee" AND a $15 parking fee on top of that! The staff was generally okay, but the manager was unpleasant and unsympathetic: I had called ahead to try and see if we could check-in 2 hours early. The staff member was able to accommodate our early check-in by giving us a small upgrade in room (premier no-view to premier with view). I thanked the staff member and was very pleased. HOWEVER, once we got there on the day of our check-in we were attended by a manager who quickly informed us that she had not 'approved' the upgrade and therefore could not check-in for another hour. She also made sure to tell us that she knew we made our reservation online (something she apparently looked down on) and that there actually were several vacant rooms at the time we arrived, but would still have to wait an hour. That was downright rude.

Review

Pros: Really pretty location and views. Process of getting in and out was awesome. Also very cute rooms.

Cons: The Ac wasn't working at first (was fixed later), our bed was extremely hard and uncomfortable, extremely noisy in the morning, and ceiling was ugly.