Keflavik Car Hire

Pros: Everything went very smooth. The car was exactly as expected, it was comfortable and drove well. the pick up and drop off process was as easy and fast.

Fair car rental in Iceland

Pros: This must be an outfit that contracts with Economy Rentals which is an outfit who knows where they are when you call and does not seem to know anything about customer services . That said, Fair Rental Car was great. Really nice people and the little Suzuki we rented took us all over Iceland thru some rocky roads. I recommend this rental company and advise going direct, skip Economy, the middle man.

Great value for money. Good car and friendly staff

Pros: Great value for money. All personnel we dealt with were very friendly. The car was in a good condition and convenient too

Cons: The pick up location was a bit far from the Keflavik airport. We wandered for 5 minutes before we figured we will be picked up

Good value, absolutely no problems with the car

Pros: No problems is really all we cared about. Everything worked fine, it handled well, and had some nice features for it's class level. The staff we interacted with were very friendly and helpful.

Cons: Took a while to figure out the cruise control since the only manual was in German and it wasn't like anything I have used before. Noticed a lot of "hot" smell towards the end of the trip and told the drop-off person that the oil I would say was closer to tar than what I would run in my car. The airport pickup was a small problem because the rental site stated airport pickup, which it wasn't. We found out by an airport information person that we actually should look for someone with a sign (there were a lot of them) and the person was about half an hour late from our stated rental start time that I signed up for so I was almost to the point where I was looking at hiring a cab at midnight and dealing with the rental the next day after we had slept. Once the person arrived, he was great and he explained that he had waited so as to combine another pickup, but we obviously didn't know anything about that so we thought we had gotten forgotten or dumped.

Great budget car rental

Pros: The rental location is off the airport by a few miles but there was a lady waiting to drive us there. Our flight was delayed and we showed up an hour after our planned arrival time and she still waited for us (at 5am)! Check in was quick and easy and they gave us a free Garmin for time in Iceland. The car was a bit older but drove well and didn't have any major issues. This was perfect for our iceland road trip and I will definitely book there again.

great rental experience, once we figured out how t

Pros: Older but very well-maintained car. Great price, friendly service.

Cons: There's no sign for Economy or FairCar at the airport! If you give them your flight info, they'll pick you up when you land, but if you somehow miss each other, then you'll have to call for a ride. Just 5 minutes from the airport, but there's no trace of the company anywhere at the airport. They're legit, though -- just communicate with them before you land, or call when you arrive.