Skip to main content
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Put-in-Bay resorts
Search hundreds of travel sites at once for resorts in Put-in-Bay
Compare vs KAYAK
Best Put-in-Bay resorts
"Situated in Put-in-Bay, this cottage is within a 15-minute walk of Lake Erie, South Bass Island State Park and Heineman Winery. Stonehenge and Perry's Cave are also within 1 mile (2 km). "
Overall 8.6 Excellent
Based on 197 reviews
All
- All
- Families with older children
- Families with young children
- Families
- Young couples
- Couples
- Groups
- Solo travellers
- Business travellers
Good
7.4
Excellent
8.5
Pros: We stayed in the two bedroom Cottage. We thought that there would be only one bed in each room. However, there was an extra bed in one of the rooms. The cottage was very comfy and roomy. Even though the pool was a disaster, I loved staying here.
Cons: The pool was not clean. You couldn’t even see the bottom of the pool. Very disappointing.
Excellent
8.5
Pros: Nice quiet location
Cons: Beds and pillows we're very uncomfortable!
"Situated on a lake, this hotel is within a 10-minute walk of Oak Point State Park, Lake Erie Islands Historical Society and DeRivera Park. Heineman Winery and Lake Erie are also within 10 minutes. "
Overall 7.5 Good
Based on 311 reviews
All
- All
- Families
- Young couples
- Couples
- Groups
- Solo travellers
- Business travellers
Okay
5.4
Pros: The front desk help was great and efficient. It was close to downtown and an easy walk.
Cons: The room was kind of dirty- hair in the bathroom and tub and I was afraid to have my shoes off on the carpet (it was gross). One of the workers walked right in our room without knocking. The "breakfast" was pitiful. Definitely not worth what I paid to stay there.
Excellent
8.8
Pros: The hotel looked better in person then from the pictures. The room we stayed in was updated and for the most part clean. Very close to the downtown areas.
Cons: I didn't like that they didn't have breakfast on Saturdays. To me that's pretty wack. But it did give us a chance to try out resturants. But I didn't like that. I also noticed slight carpet stains in a few areas of our room. It looked liked it had been scrubbed but still slightly present
"Situated in Put-in-Bay, this hotel is within a 10-minute walk of Oak Point State Park, Lake Erie Islands Historical Society and Stonehenge. DeRivera Park and Aquatic Resource Center are also within 10 minutes. "
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 674 reviews
All
- All
- Families
- Couples
- Groups
- Solo travellers
- Business travellers
Excellent
8.0
Okay
4.8
Pros: The fact it was on the island.
Cons: Within 2 hours of being at the resort sitting at the pool, my phone was stolen. The staff was less than helpful, the police less than helpful. Two hours into a weekend and it was ruined, they let locals in and marked me clearly to take advantage of me. Convenient the one spot I sat at had no camera coverage. Avoid unless in a group.
Where to stay in Put-in-Bay?
Our map will help you find the perfect place to stay in Put-in-Bay by showing you the exact location of each resort.