Skip to main content
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Best New Paltz motels
Situated in New Paltz, this motel is within 2 miles (3 km) of State University of New York-New Paltz, Huguenot Street Historic District and G. Steve Jordan Gallery. Loren Campbell Memorial Field and New Paltz Golf Course are also within 3 miles (5 km).
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 710 reviews
All
- All
- Families with older children
- Families with young children
- Families
- Mature couples
- Young couples
- Couples
- Groups
- Solo travellers
- Business travellers
Excellent
9.1
Pros: Clean and somewhat quiet
Cons: Pillows were half the size
Excellent
8.0
Excellent
9.7
Pros: Everything was great! Great value and perfect location to visit the SUNY New Paltz University!
Excellent
8.5
Pros: It was a good value for the money, conveniently located and had a surprisingly good little breakfast for such a small hotel. Suggest that you advertise Free Wi-Fi because we almost cancelled our reservation because nowhere was that listed!
Cons: The fact that the hotel was under renovation and had no hot water-rather inconvenient!
Excellent
8.8
Pros: clean breakfast included close to New Paltz Village without being too close easy access to main highways
Cons: Entrance is easy to miss on Terwillinger Street
Okay
4.8
Pros: The staff was very friendly
Cons: The biggest problem was the HVAC unit in the room. The mechanicals were so noisy that I was awakened every time the unit went on. It sounded very very dated. Another issue were the dust mites that got my allergies going. This was not unexpected. Overall, the hotel was an inexpensive place to rest my head that is need of an update. In a pinch it would do.
Good
6.2
Pros: The room was simple and clean. The staff was friendly and helpful and the price was right.
Cons: Lots of cigarette butts outside despite the receptacle provided. That's on some rude guests but a sign or two might help.
Located in the heart of New Paltz, this motel is within 3 miles (5 km) of State University of New York-New Paltz, Apple Greens Golf Course and G. Steve Jordan Gallery. Huguenot Street Historic District and Loren Campbell Memorial Field are also within 3 miles (5 km).
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 185 reviews
All
- All
- Families with older children
- Families with young children
- Families
- Young couples
- Couples
- Groups
- Solo travellers
- Business travellers
Mediocre
2.0
Good
7.7
Excellent
9.1
Pros: Value
Cons: '
Mediocre
3.4
Pros: Location was convenient.
Cons: Checkout was at 11am, we started to pack up at 10:45 and went back to grab our last bags and they had put a lock on our room. We had to get our key reactivated. Also, I had booked through an online company and they printed out a receipt with my name on it, but someone else's credit card and information. No apologies. Breakfast was poor, room was cold and the TV kept turning off.
Mediocre
3.1
Pros: Out of all the hotels in new paltz, it's the least of the rundown hotels.
Cons: Linens are disgusting--bring your own. Large dark red stain on the teal fleece blanket. Disgusting.
Okay
5.1
Pros: Outside is nice and renovated. Front desk curteous.
Cons: By far the dirtiest room I've ever stayed at and I've stayed at a lot of cheap motels. Table was sticky and had crumbs on it. Dirty dirty floor seemed it had not been cleaned in years.
Okay
4.0
Cons: Checked in after the 2 PM check-in time and was told they were just readying the rooms then. Door was difficult to open since clearance was too low. Deadbolt on door non-operational. Worse issue was the mold in the bathroom. Toilet did not flush enough to empty. Tried to check out the following morning but lobby was locked. Went outdoors and tried ringing bell several times at lobby door. After 20 minutes, clerk came to door in his bare feet (walking through breakfast area), seemed annoyed that I had awakened him (even though by that time it was about 10 minutes prior to when they said breakfast would be out). Did not stay for the breakfast. Saw that the cereals were kept out in dispensers when I checked in the earlier day so I had doubts about their freshness/closure from insects.
Excellent
8.8
Pros: The New Paltz Rodeway Inn & Suites was conveniently located, with easy accessibility to the highway and a short drive to the college, yet it was quiet at night with no road noise. The rooms and public areas were very clean, and the staff was friendly and attentive. The hotel offered a standard continental breakfast in the morning. I understand that this property has recently come under new management and the new proprietor is eager to continue to make improvements.
Mediocre
2.2
Pros: Not much.
Cons: Dirty sheets, odd smell, hovering staff over the poor continental breakfast...
Good
6.0
Pros: Rundown but at least clean.
Cons: Non-smoking room kind of smelled like pipe smoke (and had what looked like cigarette burns on the bathroom counter and tub)
Okay
4.5
Pros: It was a basic room. I would would only stay for one night tops.
Cons: There was hairs in the bed and on the bathroom counter. The sink wasnt draining from the very beginning and once it filled with water it started leaking from underneath and counter. We used the garbage can to put underneath to stop it from flooding all over the floor.
Where to stay in New Paltz?
Our map will help you find the perfect place to stay in New Paltz by showing you the exact location of each motel.