Find Cheap Flights from New York to Toronto Island (NYC - YTZ)

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to Toronto Island

Depart
Return
Any month
Compare vs KAYAK |

New York to Toronto Island flight information

Avg. flight duration 1h 35m
Flights arrive in Toronto Island
Flights depart from New York
Flight price £209
Distance 341 miles
Airlines Porter Airlines, Air Canada

Good to know

Low season:
November
Best time to beat the crowds
2%
expected price decrease
High season:
August
Most popular time to fly
1%
expected price increase
Average price:
£236
(price for this month)
Good deal:
£181
or less return trip within
2 months
of travel is a good deal

When to Book Flights from New York to Toronto Island

Average price per month
Flight prices as travel date approaches
-1 day
-2 days

Top tips for finding a cheap flight

The cheapest flight from New York to Toronto Island was found, on average, 30 days before departure.
Book at least 2 weeks before departure in order to get a below-average price.
High season is considered to be July, August and September. The cheapest month to fly is November.
Morning departure is around 175% more expensive than an evening flight, on average*.
*Average of the lowest prices shown in KAYAK’s search results for departures within the next 30 days

FAQs for Booking New York to Toronto Island Flights

How long does a flight from New York to Toronto Island take?
An average non-stop flight takes 1h 40m, covering a distance of 341 miles.
How many flights are there between New York and Toronto Island?
There are 152 (non-stop) flights between New York and Toronto Island per week, averaging 22 per day.
Which airlines provide the cheapest flights from New York to Toronto Island?
In the past 3 days, the cheapest return tickets were found on Porter Airlines (£209) and Air Canada (£264)
Which airlines fly most frequently between New York and Toronto Island?
Porter Airlines (21 times daily) are the most frequent flyers on this route.
What’s the cheapest day of the week to fly from New York to Toronto Island?
For New York to Toronto Island, Friday is the cheapest day to fly on average and Saturday is the most expensive. Flying from Toronto Island back to New York, the best deals are generally found on Sunday, with Friday being the most expensive.

Book cheap flights from New York to Toronto Island (return)

Airports
Origin
New York
£264
only
£264
Newark
£209
only
£209
Destination
Toronto
£209
only
£209
Fri, 22 Feb
EWR
Newark
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 40m
Mon, 25 Feb
YTZ
Toronto Island
EWR
Newark
1h 30m
£209
Trip: 4 days
8.0ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.0 Excellent
Based on 239 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Good 6.6

Pros: Airport

Cons: Was late going to NewYork and coming home. We were able to get an early flight which was great. Island Aurpirt is wonderful. Price fantastic!

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Great service! Attentive staff. Fabulous free lounges with drinks and snacks. Cappuccino in real cups in Toronto. Free wine and beer on flights. Real glasses on flights and in Toronto lounge. Gate agents were friendly and so helpful. Nrwark had a nice smaller lounge. Lots of legroom on flights.

Cons: You have to be aware that these are props, so flights do get delayed or cancelled due to weather. Both of our flights were delayed. But they were very up front about it. Also put us on earlier flights automatically which was nice.

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Wasn’t warned on website about applying for ETA. Airline didn’t accommodate me in this situation and proceed to charge me $100 to change my flight.

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Cons: Delay

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Pros: I was so happy to have been bumped up to an earlier flight so easily! The staff was very friendly and the trip was very enjoyable

Fri, 22 Mar
LGA
New York LaGuardia
YTZ
Toronto Island
6h 00m
Mon, 25 Mar
YTZ
Toronto Island
LGA
New York LaGuardia
5h 06m
£264
Trip: 4 days
7.1GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 23,555 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.9
Food
6.5
YYZ
YVR
OK 5.3

Pros: The movies.

Cons: Seat size

YVR
SAN
Excellent 8.0

Pros: On time.

YYC
FRA
Good 7.0

Pros: The ✈️ and timing

Cons: Amounts of food is ridiculously little for someone who gets hungry fast

YYZ
YVR
Good 6.3

Pros: Nice plane looks new

SEA
YVR
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Cancelled 30 minute flight up to Vancouver which reaulted in missed flight to Australia. Air Canada the refused to put us on another flight. Went round and round for 5 hours with Air Canada until they finally put us on 3 separate flights getting to our deatination almost 48 hours late.Horrible

Cons: Notify passengers if short flight has more than 20% chance of being cancelled. We could have easily driven to Vancouver. If flight is cancelled, then own up to it and put people on next flight.

Sat, 13 Apr
LGA
New York LaGuardia
YTZ
Toronto Island
5h 00m
Tue, 16 Apr
YTZ
Toronto Island
LGA
New York LaGuardia
3h 54m
£264
Trip: 4 days
7.1GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 23,555 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.9
Food
6.5
MEX
YVR
OK 5.0

Pros: . The staff was and movies waa the only good part of the flight.

Cons: I upgraded my seat and I couldn't even recline it. 6 hours in an upright position. If I would if know this I wouldn't of upgraded to that seat I actually would like a refund in this as well. Waste is money

LHR
YOW
Excellent 8.0

Cons: Not enough movie options

PVG
YUL
Excellent 8.0

Pros: Good service good flight fair food and nice seat.

Cons: Biggest issue the start very lax re security, 2 people never wore their seatbelts at any time, take off and landing. They hardly checked anything.

YVR
YZF
OK 4.5

Pros: Crew was friendly

Cons: Not being 3.5 hours late

YYZ
YVR
OK 5.3

Pros: The movies.

Cons: It’s a crowded plane with tiny seats. The passengers in my row who had not been able to bathe did not make the 5 hours go by quickly.

Fri, 22 Feb
LGA
New York LaGuardia
YTZ
Toronto Island
6h 00m
Mon, 25 Feb
YTZ
Toronto Island
LGA
New York LaGuardia
6h 01m
£309
Trip: 4 days
7.1GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 23,555 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.9
Food
6.5
YYZ
YEG
Excellent 8.6

Pros: Crew was great. Especially Reagan

Cons: Poor choice of movies

YYZ
LAX
Good 6.3

Pros: I like that the pilot to managed to take off in the snowy conditions and arrived our destination LA our time. The crew was amicable. That was it really.

Cons: I felt the plane was not very comfortable for a 5 1/2hr flight. I will not fly this plane never on transatlantic it just not cozy like big airbus or b777. Air Canada should invest in big planes if it want to cash out on the passengers connecting their pacific flights.

SEA
YVR
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Cancelled 30 minute flight up to Vancouver which reaulted in missed flight to Australia. Air Canada the refused to put us on another flight. Went round and round for 5 hours with Air Canada until they finally put us on 3 separate flights getting to our deatination almost 48 hours late.Horrible

Cons: Notify passengers if short flight has more than 20% chance of being cancelled. We could have easily driven to Vancouver. If flight is cancelled, then own up to it and put people on next flight.

MEX
YVR
OK 5.0

Pros: . The staff was and movies waa the only good part of the flight.

Cons: I upgraded my seat and I couldn't even recline it. 6 hours in an upright position. If I would if know this I wouldn't of upgraded to that seat I actually would like a refund in this as well. Waste is money

LGA
YYZ
Good 6.3

Pros: The seat is reasonably comfortable. One of the flight attendants was full of smiles and very friendly, which was so nice.

Cons: The audio jack for the entertainment system was not working. The food was basically only a cup of beverage and mini pretzels.

Sat, 10 Aug
LGA
New York LaGuardia
YTZ
Toronto Island
5h 00m
Thu, 22 Aug
YTZ
Toronto Island
LGA
New York LaGuardia
4h 04m
£309
Trip: 13 days
7.1GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 23,555 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.9
Food
6.5
MSP
YYZ
Excellent 9.3

Pros: Great service, easy boarding, good flight.

Cons: Cramped seats, like everyone.

YYZ
ORD
OK 5.0

Cons: Poor oversight by gate staff on limited carry-on luggage space caused departure delay, easily avoided for next time.

YYZ
YVR
Good 6.3

Pros: Nice plane looks new

YYZ
YVR
OK 5.3

Pros: The movies.

Cons: It’s a crowded plane with tiny seats. The passengers in my row who had not been able to bathe did not make the 5 hours go by quickly.

CMN
YUL
OK 5.0

Pros: No food , no entertainment options .

Cons: Have the option to purchase food on a 5 hour flight .

Fri, 28 Jun
LGA
New York LaGuardia
YTZ
Toronto Island
5h 00m
Tue, 2 Jul
YTZ
Toronto Island
LGA
New York LaGuardia
5h 39m
£312
Trip: 5 days
7.1GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 23,555 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.9
Food
6.5
YYZ
LAS
Mediocre 3.6

Pros: Crew was responsive

Cons: Late departure, sitting on the tarmack for hours, most uncomfortable seats

YUL
EWR
Good 7.2

Pros: The boarding was good and effective, Entertainment was good.

Cons: The crew did not pay attention to my requests for beverages and forgot to bring me what I have asked.

YHZ
YYZ
Good 7.3

Cons: We had a 5:35 am flight and the plane was 1/2 hour late to gate. By the time it got there, we spent over 1 hour sitting at gate loaded up waiting for weather to clear. It was fine when it was supposed to be there. Therefore, this was not initially a weather issue. Our connecting flight is 12 hours after Our schedules flight. I have a 1 year old toddler. Customer service rep less than sympathetic personality.

YVR
TPE
Excellent 8.0

Pros: Crew is very friendly and helpful. Leg space is bigger than other flights.

Cons: Food is not as good as before. I could smell the restroom from my seat (41H). Hopefully Air Canada flights can depart and arrive on time.

LGA
YYZ
Good 6.3

Pros: The seat is reasonably comfortable. One of the flight attendants was full of smiles and very friendly, which was so nice.

Cons: The audio jack for the entertainment system was not working. The food was basically only a cup of beverage and mini pretzels.

Fri, 22 Feb
LGA
New York LaGuardia
YTZ
Toronto Island
5h 45m
Sun, 24 Feb
YTZ
Toronto Island
LGA
New York LaGuardia
4h 44m
£345
Trip: 3 days
7.1GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 23,555 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.9
Food
6.5
YYZ
BOS
Good 6.4

Pros: Short of the entertainment system incident, the service was pleasant. It was nice to NOT be on a full flight and have both seats to myself.

Cons: Entertainment system was not working, and crew was fairly nonchalant about it. In the past they at least apologized and on the better end gave out drink vouchers. Not this time.

SEA
YVR
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Cancelled 30 minute flight up to Vancouver which reaulted in missed flight to Australia. Air Canada the refused to put us on another flight. Went round and round for 5 hours with Air Canada until they finally put us on 3 separate flights getting to our deatination almost 48 hours late.Horrible

Cons: Notify passengers if short flight has more than 20% chance of being cancelled. We could have easily driven to Vancouver. If flight is cancelled, then own up to it and put people on next flight.

PVG
YUL
Excellent 8.0

Pros: Good service good flight fair food and nice seat.

Cons: Biggest issue the start very lax re security, 2 people never wore their seatbelts at any time, take off and landing. They hardly checked anything.

YYZ
ORD
OK 5.0

Cons: Poor oversight by gate staff on limited carry-on luggage space caused departure delay, easily avoided for next time.

MCO
YYZ
OK 4.6

Cons: 7 flight delays, over 1 hr 20 min to board, poor service, reboot entertainment system 4 times

Show more results
*
Prices are per person, are for e–tickets and include all taxes & fees in GBP.

We attempt to get accurate prices, however, prices are not guaranteed.

Here's why:

We’re not the seller
At KAYAK we don’t set prices, so it’s not possible for us to guarantee what other companies are selling.

We aggregate tons of data for you
Our service lets you quickly and easily compare results from hundreds of travel sites at once. In this sense, KAYAK is a search engine and we don't guarantee prices we find.

Why aren’t prices accurate 100% of the time?
Prices on airline seats, hotel rooms and car hires can change frequently. Several people may also be trying to buy the same travel option simultaneously. As a result, you may find on occasion that certain prices are no longer available.

More questions or if you have a bad price to report to us
Please send us an and someone from our team will get back to you promptly.

^
The fares displayed include all taxes and fees for economy class travel and were found by the provider in the last 72 hours. Seats are limited and may not be available on all flights and days. Fares are subject to change and may not be available on all flights or dates of travel. Some carriers charge additional fees for extra checked bags. Please check the carriers' sites.