Find cheap flights from New York to Toronto Island

NYC - YTZ

Find cheap flights from New York to Toronto Island

Return
Economy
New York (NYC)
Toronto Island
Fri 27/3
Fri 3/4
Any month
Compare vs KAYAK |
Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to Toronto Island

Good to know

Low season: April
High season: August
Average price: £199
Good deal: £198

Best time to beat the crowds

3%

expected price decrease

Most popular time to fly

0%

expected price increase

(price for this month)

or less for a return flight within

4 months

of your travel date is a good deal

When to book flights from New York to Toronto Island

Average price per month
Flight prices as travel date approaches
-1 day
-2 days

Top tips for finding a cheap flight

  • The cheapest flight from New York to Toronto Island was found, on average, 73 days before departure.
  • Book at least 3 weeks before departure in order to get a below-average price.
  • High season is considered to be July, August and September. The cheapest month to fly is April.

FAQs for booking New York to Toronto Island flights

How does KAYAK’s flight Price Forecast tool help me choose the right time to buy?
KAYAK’s flight Price Forecast tool uses historical data to determine whether the price for a given destination and date is likely to change within 7 days, so travellers know whether to wait or book now.

Book cheap flights from New York to Toronto Island (one-way)

Airports
Origin
New York
£96
only
£96
Newark
£47
only
£47
Destination
Toronto
£47
only
£47
Sat, 20 Jun
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 40m
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Wasn’t warned on website about applying for ETA. Airline didn’t accommodate me in this situation and proceed to charge me $100 to change my flight.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: I have flown on Porter numerous time but this was the first for my family. They enjoyed the Porter lounge and convenience of flying from the Toronto island right into EWR. We were able to take the NJ Train right to Penn Station (NYC) faster than any taxi.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.4

Pros: Everything went as planned.

Cons: USB or power outlets.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 9.3

Cons: Boarding was confusing

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Why would you go any other way? Dependable service, complimentary in-flight wine, the world's best shortbread cookies, breeze through customs and the arrival gate is within walking distance of your hotel.

Cons: Are you kidding?

Mon, 8 Jun
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 40m
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Due to unforeseen circumstances, we arrived at 9:00 for a 10:10 flight, and so were not allowed to try to go through customs to make the flight. When we asked if they could put us on the next flight and we'd pay the $100 plus dollars each to do so, as we realized that we were at fault for arriving late, we were told that they wouldn't do this for us because we had booked through Kayak and not through Porter directly. We were then told that we would have to pay full price for new tickets, over $800. I can't afford to pay another $800 and told them so. I realized we were late, but to be told that they could do nothing for us was horrible. They finally said they'd do it after we told them about our horrendous experience with them on our flight to New York, but then wouldn't let us take our carry on luggage on the flight and charged us a further $60 to put it in the hold. We were then told that they could only get us as far as Toronto, (AFTER we'd paid the extra money) and we'd have to find another way home from there. We live in Ottawa, that's a 6 hour drive, and neither I nor my son drive. It was an absolute nightmare getting back from Toronto, and we didn't get home until 1:00 a.m. Shame on you Kayak and Porter airlines. Our flight to New York was a nightmare (see my other email) and so was our flight home. I know you won't do anything about this and don't care about your customers, but I can assure you that I will be posting as many negative things that I can on social media, and will tell everyone I know never to fly with Porter airlines. Shame on you.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: The flight

Cons: It was on time for once coming back Toronto

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Pros: Crew perks and helpful staff

Cons: Short time between transfers and delay

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: I needed to cancel my flight and due to the coronavirus outbreak I couldn't get in touch with anyone in time and wasn't able to cancel. I didn't get on my flight and still can't get in touch with anyone

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Wasn’t warned on website about applying for ETA. Airline didn’t accommodate me in this situation and proceed to charge me $100 to change my flight.

Mon, 8 Jun
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 40m
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Good 6.3

Pros: Snack selection and free alcohol is good and unique; Porter is great for these short trips.

Cons: I like the comfortable seats and the 2-2 configuration (no middle seats) but hate the no overhead space.

EWR
YTZ
Okay 4.0

Cons: No carry on baggage fee

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Service was great

EWR
YTZ
Good 7.0

Pros: I very much enjoyed the ease of traveling on Porter. It was essentially hassle free. It was also a nice change to have a choice of snacks.

Cons: We experienced a turbulent ride which of course was no fault of Porter. There was no entertainment.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: The courteous and helpful nature of both the ground staff and the crew. The Coffee was super.

Cons: No Complaints whatsoever

Thu, 4 Jun
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 38m
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: No issues. Everything took place on time. The staff were very accommodating and patient with the infants on board

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 3.3

Pros: 3 hours delay

Cons: Be on time.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Yed

Cons: If the flight is over Nigara , a brief commentary on Nigara will enthuse the passengers.

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Cons: Would have been nice if we weren’t 2 hours late. Or if the people working at the gate were nice. Or if our bags weren’t hidden in some part of baggage claim with no announcement on where to find them. I’ll never fly porter again.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Pros: Crew perks and helpful staff

Cons: Short time between transfers and delay

Sat, 22 Aug
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 45m
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Everything

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Cons: Canceling flights with no notice and rescheduling made me lose a day

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Pros: I was so happy to have been bumped up to an earlier flight so easily! The staff was very friendly and the trip was very enjoyable

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: The courteous and helpful nature of both the ground staff and the crew. The Coffee was super.

Cons: No Complaints whatsoever

EWR
YTZ
Okay 5.0

Pros: The flight attendants were nice and pleasant

Sun, 24 May
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 40m
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Cons: Flight took off 30 min late

EWR
YTZ
Okay 5.0

Pros: Everything was alright until I missed my flight to Montreal because the connecting flight was late

Cons: If I actually made it to mtl, stuck in Toronto

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Changed and Billy Bishop Airport in Toronto. Porter has a great little facility there that really treats the passengers well. Both flights to and from Toronto were great.

Cons: Changed and Billy Bishop Airport in Toronto. Porter has a great little facility there that really treats the passengers well. Both flights to and from Toronto were great.

EWR
YTZ
Good 7.0

Pros: Too short a flight that no entertainment is necessary

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 9.6

Pros: The crew was very nice, and I love the complimentary craft beer!

Thu, 30 Apr
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 45m
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Changed and Billy Bishop Airport in Toronto. Porter has a great little facility there that really treats the passengers well. Both flights to and from Toronto were great.

Cons: Changed and Billy Bishop Airport in Toronto. Porter has a great little facility there that really treats the passengers well. Both flights to and from Toronto were great.

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Pros: Once our plane finally got there the crew and people working the desk were super efficient and concentrated on getting us on our way ASAP.

Cons: We were 6 hours delayed. The weather was bad so it wasn’t anyone’s fault. It just sucked.

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Wasn’t warned on website about applying for ETA. Airline didn’t accommodate me in this situation and proceed to charge me $100 to change my flight.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Why would you go any other way? Dependable service, complimentary in-flight wine, the world's best shortbread cookies, breeze through customs and the arrival gate is within walking distance of your hotel.

Cons: Are you kidding?

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Nice flight attendants, service, and landing!

Fri, 15 May
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 35m
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Pros: Crew perks and helpful staff

Cons: Short time between transfers and delay

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Everything

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: The flight

Cons: It was on time for once coming back Toronto

EWR
YTZ
Okay 5.6

Cons: I was caught off guard to find out at time of check-in that I had to pay a substantial amount for carry-on when I had specifically asked for a carry-on not just a personal item when booking my reservation. I ended up paying more than saving where I could gone with another company.VERY DISAPPOINTED

EWR
YTZ
Good 7.0

Pros: Too short a flight that no entertainment is necessary

Fri, 1 May
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 45m
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Yed

Cons: If the flight is over Nigara , a brief commentary on Nigara will enthuse the passengers.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: No issues. Everything took place on time. The staff were very accommodating and patient with the infants on board

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 9.3

Cons: Boarding was confusing

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Wasn’t warned on website about applying for ETA. Airline didn’t accommodate me in this situation and proceed to charge me $100 to change my flight.

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Pros: Staff was pleasant

Cons: Missed the concert I went to see. Total disaster.

Fri, 8 May
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 39m
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 9.0

Pros: After taking a chance on an airline I had never heard of, we were pleasantly surprised! Although there was a weather related delay, they accommodated us on an earlier flight.

Cons: The plane was a bit loud

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Very polite

Cons: Nothing. This’s my first trip with Porter. Excellent in everything.

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Pros: Snack options, flight attendants

Cons: Flight was delayed only a few minutes before initial boarding. The inconsistent communication ‘tween screens, loud speaker, & sent to my phone lead me to wait on line to speak to the person at the gate for clarity-when my turn came he did not help me but some pushy other passenger despite my protest

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Lounge Wine

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Pros: Staff was pleasant

Cons: Missed the concert I went to see. Total disaster.

Tue, 14 Jul
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 39m
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Okay 5.0

Pros: Everything was alright until I missed my flight to Montreal because the connecting flight was late

Cons: If I actually made it to mtl, stuck in Toronto

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: The flight

Cons: It was on time for once coming back Toronto

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 9.0

Pros: After taking a chance on an airline I had never heard of, we were pleasantly surprised! Although there was a weather related delay, they accommodated us on an earlier flight.

Cons: The plane was a bit loud

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Pros: Was offered a earlier flight that was available when we arrived for check in

Cons: I thought I had paid for baggage in advance but obviously there was a glitch in the payment process so HATED the cost for 2 bags. We traveled with 6 other airlines within Europe and none charged this exorbitant amount... NOT VERY PLEASED Check in person wasn’t very pleasant to deal with. I think she was having a bad day!!! All other staff and flight attendants were pleasant and good to deal with.

EWR
YTZ
Good 7.0

Pros: I very much enjoyed the ease of traveling on Porter. It was essentially hassle free. It was also a nice change to have a choice of snacks.

Cons: We experienced a turbulent ride which of course was no fault of Porter. There was no entertainment.

Wed, 22 Apr
LGA
New York LaGuardia Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
23h 47m
Based on 0 reviews
Fri, 4 Sep
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 38m
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Porter was great, bumped us up to an earlier flight because we had no checked baggage

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 9.0

Pros: After taking a chance on an airline I had never heard of, we were pleasantly surprised! Although there was a weather related delay, they accommodated us on an earlier flight.

Cons: The plane was a bit loud

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Pros: Staff was pleasant

Cons: Missed the concert I went to see. Total disaster.

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Cons: Plane too small and noisy

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Service was great

Sat, 22 Aug
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 45m
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Yed

Cons: If the flight is over Nigara , a brief commentary on Nigara will enthuse the passengers.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Pros: Was offered a earlier flight that was available when we arrived for check in

Cons: I thought I had paid for baggage in advance but obviously there was a glitch in the payment process so HATED the cost for 2 bags. We traveled with 6 other airlines within Europe and none charged this exorbitant amount... NOT VERY PLEASED Check in person wasn’t very pleasant to deal with. I think she was having a bad day!!! All other staff and flight attendants were pleasant and good to deal with.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Very polite

Cons: Nothing. This’s my first trip with Porter. Excellent in everything.

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Bunch of crooks gave me the wrong time. Missed my flight

Cons: Getting correct to information

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.4

Pros: Everything went as planned.

Cons: USB or power outlets.

Fri, 31 Jul
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 40m
£100
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Wasn’t warned on website about applying for ETA. Airline didn’t accommodate me in this situation and proceed to charge me $100 to change my flight.

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 3.3

Pros: 3 hours delay

Cons: Be on time.

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Cons: The flight was delayed by 2 hours and I received no notification of this delay. I checked in on the Porter website and provided my email and phone number to notify me of any chances. I took a $100 taxi ride as opposed to the slower $15 train ride thinking the flight was on time. Absolutely not impressed

EWR
YTZ
Okay 5.6

Cons: I was caught off guard to find out at time of check-in that I had to pay a substantial amount for carry-on when I had specifically asked for a carry-on not just a personal item when booking my reservation. I ended up paying more than saving where I could gone with another company.VERY DISAPPOINTED

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Cons: Flight took off 30 min late

Fri, 3 Jul
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 29m
£101
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Pros: Once our plane finally got there the crew and people working the desk were super efficient and concentrated on getting us on our way ASAP.

Cons: We were 6 hours delayed. The weather was bad so it wasn’t anyone’s fault. It just sucked.

EWR
YTZ
Okay 5.0

Pros: Cheaper than other airlines though the flight attendants are really great

Cons: Well you get what you pay Small plane, not as confortable seats

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 9.3

Cons: Boarding was confusing

EWR
YTZ
Good 7.6

Pros: The gate agent blocked the seat next to me aonI had the whole row to myself. Porter is the best way to get to Toronto from the Philadelphia and NY area

Cons: The flight attendant nearly took my hand off when offering the snacks. Usually the insist Intake more.

EWR
YTZ
Okay 5.0

Pros: The flight attendants were nice and pleasant

Thu, 23 Apr
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 38m
£104
7.9Good Show reviews
Overall 7.9 Good
Based on 277 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Good 7.0

Pros: Convenience of the airport location which is steps from downtown Toronto. Friendly crew and descent snacks.

Cons: Porter flights are almost always delayed. I take them pretty often and they are almost never on time, especially the late afternoon / evenings flights. This time the plane had some problems with AC and was too hot.

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Pros: Snack options, flight attendants

Cons: Flight was delayed only a few minutes before initial boarding. The inconsistent communication ‘tween screens, loud speaker, & sent to my phone lead me to wait on line to speak to the person at the gate for clarity-when my turn came he did not help me but some pushy other passenger despite my protest

EWR
YTZ
Good 7.0

Pros: Too short a flight that no entertainment is necessary

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Cons: Flight took off 30 min late

EWR
YTZ
Okay 4.8

Cons: Flight was very delayed. We got turned around in flight and then ultimately made it. No apologies from crew or porter.

Fri, 24 Apr
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
13h 51m
£110
Based on 0 reviews
Thu, 30 Apr
EWR
Newark Liberty Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
11h 41m
£113
Based on 0 reviews
Tue, 21 Apr
LGA
New York LaGuardia Airport
YTZ
Toronto Island
18h 07m
£114
Based on 0 reviews
Show more results
-
1
  • Return
  • One-way
  • Multi-city
  • Trip Builder
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
  • Multiple
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First